OPen

A Strategy is Not a Plan: The Chessboard of Business

Business & Strategy
/
February 17, 2024
An image of a chess board with written text: strategy is not a plan.

Dive into my perspective on the crucial differences between strategy and planning in my business exploration. This insight reflects my viewpoint on why embracing a strategic approach is vital for businesses aiming to win. In stark contrast to the comforting, yet limiting confines of planning.

In the grand tapestry of business, where every move can turn the tide of fortune, there lies a fundamental misunderstanding that has led many to falter in their quest for success. It's the confusion between strategy and planning—two concepts often used interchangeably but inherently distinct in nature and purpose. Understanding this distinction is not just an exercise in semantics; it is the core of navigating the business world with agility and foresight.

A image of a person looking ahead.
OPen

Strategy: The Vision Beyond the Plan

Strategy is not merely a list of actions; it's a vision that anticipates market shifts, embraces uncertainty, and creates a path to long-term success. It's akin to the chess master who plans several moves ahead, not just the next step. Strategy is about asking, "What do we believe will happen if we make this move?" It's a declaration of belief that guides a company through uncharted waters, allowing for adaptation and growth in an ever-changing market.

In the nuanced fabric of business dynamics, strategy is inherently customer-centric, aiming to deepen the understanding of customer needs and desires to foster new value. It peers outward, into the market, to carve out a unique position that resonates with those we aim to serve.

Planning: The Comfort of Control

Planning, on the other hand, focuses inward, organizing resources and processes to achieve specific objectives. It offers stability and a sense of control, but it often lacks the flexibility needed to adapt to unexpected changes. Planning details the "how" and "when" of achieving goals but doesn't always address the "why" or the "what if."

Imagine planning as a map drawn in the comfort of one's home, outlining the steps to reach a destination. It's a necessary tool, providing direction and structure, but it doesn’t account for detours or roadblocks. Plans are the scaffolding upon which strategies rest, necessary but not sufficient for victory.

The Chessboard Analogy: A Metaphor for Business

Consider the game of chess. It’s not merely about moving pieces on a board; it’s an intricate dance of strategy and anticipation. A player doesn’t move a pawn from A2 to A3 without cause; they strategize, envisioning the cascading effects of that move on the game’s outcome. Similarly, in business, every decision must be viewed as part of a larger picture, considering the potential reactions of competitors, market shifts, and external factors.

In this context, strategy is about thinking several moves ahead, preparing for various scenarios. Planning, meanwhile, is like focusing on the immediate next move. Both are necessary, but strategy provides the overarching vision, while planning delivers the specific steps to execute that vision.

The Business Game: ComfyCorp vs. Visionary Ventures

Let’s consider two companies: ComfyCorp and Visionary Ventures. ComfyCorp relies heavily on detailed plans. They have workflows, quarterly targets, and roadmaps for every project. Their employees find solace in the predictability of their tasks, the clarity of their objectives. Yet, when the market shifts unpredictably, as it often does, their rigidity becomes their downfall. They scramble to adapt, their plans crumbling under the weight of unforeseen challenges.

In contrast, Visionary Ventures thrives on strategy. They understand their market deeply, anticipate changes, and adapt swiftly. Their strategy isn't a straightjacket but a compass, guiding them through uncertainty. For them, angst is a catalyst, not a deterrent. They know that true success lies in navigating uncharted waters, not in sailing the calm seas of planning.

Strategic Planning: Aligning Actions with Goals

Strategic planning bridges the gap between strategy and planning, ensuring that day-to-day actions align with broader strategic goals. It’s about continuously asking, "Does this action advance our strategy?" If the answer is no, then the action shouldn’t be part of the plan. This approach turns planning into a dynamic process, driven by strategic insight rather than a rigid set of instructions.

For Visionary Ventures, strategic planning is a living document, constantly evolving as they adapt to new information and market conditions. This alignment allows them to pivot quickly without losing sight of their long-term objectives.

Norway’s Advantage: Strategic Branding in Aquaculture

Norway's salmon industry exemplifies the power of strategic branding. By emphasizing natural, fjord-based production, the industry appeals to consumer desires for authenticity and quality. This strategic narrative strengthens the brand and differentiates Norwegian salmon in a competitive market.

Smarter farmers market their salmon as produced in Norwegian fjords, emphasizing that the fish have swum in fresh water, supported by the nutrient-rich currents of the Gulf Stream. This story is not only true but also powerful. It resonates with consumers, creating a compelling image of quality and sustainability that’s difficult for competitors to match.

How do strategy and planning differ, and why is strategic thinking essential for winning in business?
A image of a person looking on a plan.

Conclusion

In the end, a plan may tell you what to do tomorrow, but a strategy will guide you on how to shape the days after. It’s not just about being in the game; it’s about playing to win. Strategy is the art of the possible, the vision that propels us forward, while planning is the meticulous execution that turns vision into reality. Together, they form the yin and yang of business success, but it’s strategy that leads the dance. Embracing strategy is embracing the courage to navigate the unknown, a testament to the bold spirit of those who play not just to participate but to win.




References:

  1. Mintzberg, H. (1994). The Rise and Fall of Strategic Planning. Free Press.
  2. Porter, M. E. (1996). What Is Strategy? Harvard Business Review.
  3. Rumelt, R. (2011). Good Strategy Bad Strategy: The Difference and Why It Matters. Crown Business.

Keywords:
business strategy, strategic planning, business planning, chessboard analogy, strategy vs. planning, business success.

Interested in discussing this topic with industry experts?


More Posts:

Sustainability
Education & Facts
Why Eating More Seafood Can Reduce Your Carbon Footprint
a futuristic black and white image of a DNA string with a cleaner and simpler background, featuring a shallow focus field.
Biosecurity
Best Practices: The Key to Improving Biosecurity in Salmon Farming
A black-and-white closeup image of an open fish farm pen also shows a fish farm pen horizon. Photo taken by Mikkel Pedersen.
Technology & Innovation
How Size and Technology Have Transformed Salmon Farming
A black an white closeup image of salmon smolt underwater.
Fish Welfare
Why Strong Smolt Are Key to Thriving Salmon Farms
A black and white image of a lumpfish.
Fish Welfare
How Effective Are Cleaner Fish in Controlling Salmon Lice in Salmon Farming?
A black and white salmon farm feeding barge.
Industry Insights
Why Fish Farming Should Be Recognized as Livestock: A Deep Dive into Aquaculture